Menu

Education Today Logo


newsletter

Education Today Cover Browse Issue

Automarking 'methodologically flawed and massively incomplete'

News Image

The NSW Teachers Federation claims that ACARA is rushing through with plans to have robots mark next year’s NAPLAN tests despite their justifications being discredited by world-leading research. A report by Dr Les Perelman from Massachusetts Institute of Technology decribes the plan as 'methodologically flawed and massively incomplete'.

Acting President of the Federation Gary Zadkovich said: “Parents, teachers and principals have not been consulted about these radical plans and students have not been prepared for such a dramatic shift. NAPLAN has been a high-stakes and controversial test and this latest development will further bewilder youngsters who are subject to such testing.

”The Australian Curriculum and Reporting Authority announced in a newsletter that they intend to use computer-robots to mark the 2018 NAPLAN tests. In justification, they cited their own anonymous 2015 report that they claim guarantees that robots can mark children’s work just as well as teachers.

"However, the ACARA paper has been carefully examined by one of the world leaders in Assessment and Writing from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Dr Les Perelman, who describes the ACARA report as, “So methodologically flawed and so massively incomplete that it cannot justify any use of AES [automated essay scoring] in scoring the NAPLAN essays.”

Dr Perelman's report, commissioned by the The Federation, claims that robots can only detect low grade attributes of writing; cannot detect the most important elements of a text; the ACARA report uses evidence and data selectively and poorly and ignores any authority critical of robot marking; robots and humans should not be used in conjunction in marking; even robots as grammar checkers are seriously flawed; overseas evidence shows robot marking discriminated against some social groups; and introducing robots will encourage regressive teaching practices.

Responding to release of Dr Perelman's report, Dr Stanley Rabinowitz, general manager of assessment and reporting at ACARA, said all NAPLAN writing tasks completed online next year would be marked by a person as well as an automated scoring system.

He said ACARA had done further research since the 2015 report, including work based on Dr Perelman's research, which would be released next month. He defended ACARA's report and said Dr Perelman and the Teachers Federation "are known critics of automated marking systems and the report findings should be viewed with this in mind."


19 Jul 2019 | National
Why are Australian teachers under so much strain? News Image

An Aussie study has found that teachers are living with unprecedented levels of stress and anxiety. Is there a conflict between our changing expectations of education and the current classroom format? Read More

18 Jul 2019 | National
Education a bright spot in slowing jobs market News Image

It’s mid-year and it’s always a quiet time before the madness leading up to Christmas, job market activity is usually slower than usual and most states are recording declines in job ad numbers, that is unless you’re in education. Read More

18 Jul 2019 | Qld
Books in Homes supporting literacy in eight regional Queensland schools News Image

The Books in Homes Program will continue in north west Queensland for another five years with Glencore extending its support by funding eight primary schools in the region. Read More

18 Jul 2019 | National
How Australian graduates can succeed in today’s job market News Image

Making the transition from education to work is a tough one, but it’s easier with a plan and skills that employers are demanding, tech skills are important but so are soft skills and an ability to keep learning. Read More

18 Jul 2019 | National
50,000 kids coding to celebrate 50th moon landing anniversary News Image

Moonhack 2019 marks the 50th anniversary of the first moon landing and will see students take part in a space-themed coding exercise to build a space-themed game. Read More