Education Today Logo


Education Today Cover Browse Issue

Marshmallow test indicates SES not future success

News Image

In the entire history of pop science, the marshmallow test has yielded some of the cutest results.

We've all seen the vision of kids presented with the option of eating marshmallow now or waiting 15 minutes and getting two.

Whether the kids struggle and give into temptation and eat the lolly or stop themselves and receive the payoff is supposed to indicate the child’s future success, after all delayed gratification is at the centre of all achievement.

All well and good, but with the introduction of a wider test group and controls for socio economic background it looks like the ability to hold off indicates something more prosaic than self-discipline, the result actually indicated whether a kid comes from a rich or poor background.

What’s more the test reinforces that the strongest factor influencing a kid’s future success is whether they come from money or not.

During the 1960s and ’70s, the marshmallow test was carried out on about 90 children enrolled in a local Stanford preschool. Years later the team revisited their test subjects to examine the correlation between an early ability to delay gratification (as represented by holding out for the second marshmallow) and later success. The positive outcomes exhibited by those who resisted temptation included higher school leaving exam scores and lower body mass index.

The new study, led by New York University’s Tyler Watts and the University of California-Irvine’s Greg Duncan and Haonan Quan, features a rejigged version of the original test. Researchers increased the sample size to more than 900 children and included a more diverse array of individuals with a range of ethnicities, income and education levels. They also analysed results while considering background factors.

The researchers found there was very little to indicate that an ability to delay gratification correlated with greater potential in the future.

For the less well-off students, there is less certainty in day to day life. There might be food in the cupboard today, but there might not be tomorrow, so you’re probably better off eating the treat now.

While for kids who come from households with better education levels and more money, it’s easier to delay gratification: the probability is there will be a marshmallow to be had later if you want it.

12 Dec 2018
Year 12 exam results aren't everything News Image

Year 12 is both a start and an ending and this period of change can be stressful. But there is help available if kids seem to be struggling with their mental health.
Read More

12 Dec 2018 | National
Bypass ATAR News Image

There are a few anxious school leavers right now, maybe they didn't get the ATAR they needed for the course they wanted or maybe they didn’t pass at all, but fear not there is more than one way to skin a cat. Read More

11 Dec 2018 | NSW
Rural school’s learning platform make for easy access learning News Image

Located on the Victoria-New South Wales (NSW) border, Wodonga Middle Years College (WMYC) has leveraged technology so every student can access education from anywhere at any time. Read More

11 Dec 2018 | National
Queenslanders best Young ICT Explorers News Image

The 2018 national winners of the Young ICT Explorers competition have been announced with teams from Queensland and Australian Capital Territory taking home the top prizes. Read More

10 Dec 2018 | International
Finland to use Aus education toolkit News Image

We’re often told to look to Finland for direction on education but the tables have been turned with the Nordic nation adopting National Excellence in School Leadership Initiative’s (NESLI) Staff Wellbeing Toolkit. Read More