Education Today Logo


Education Today Cover Browse Issue

Time to rethink ATAR?

News Image

The ATAR is the culmination of 13 years or so of learning but as ideas about educating change and universities turn to other ways of admitting students, its relevance is being questioned.

While a high ATAR does indicate a better chance of completing tertiary studies, for ATARs lower than 80 the score provides next to no indication of success at university. The ATAR’s usefulness has further diminished as the number of higher education places has increased, widening the gates to entry.

The authors of the Mitchell report, Crunching the Number, on the issue say that education should develop the foundation skills and broader capabilities required to succeed in a changing world, support effective transitions from school to post-school life and enable more school leavers to participate in tertiary study or training.

Only one in four university admissions was based on the ATAR, the report found.

The ATAR simplifies a complex range of inputs, it can mask where students have excelled or performed poorly, and reduces the rich skills, knowledge and capabilities students develop over 13 years of schooling to one number, the report states.

The ranking of all final year school students on a single scale from 0 to 99.95 is unique to Australia and causes distortions, universities are cornered into playing a shell game with ATARs, setting entrance requirements for courses high so as not to dilute their prestige while admitting students through late and early round offers and other entrance criteria. Students shy from tougher subjects attempting to score well in the test.

The system is clearly turning into a case of chase the ATAR rather than seek the best outcomes for students and their futures.

Many comparable countries are tempering reliance on a single figure, in Singapore students are evaluated based on individual grades obtained in four content-based subjects, as well as a general critical thinking subject, and an extended group learning project. Some faculties have additional requirements such as interviews or aptitude tests.

An increasing number of universities in the UK have shunned the A levels and set their own entrance exams while US Universities require students to provide their achievement scores on a standardised aptitude test, the Scholastic Assessment Test (SAT) which usually combines with essays on personal achievements.

Australian universities are increasingly turning to aptitude tests to assess applicants to their most prestigious courses.

The Undergraduate Medicine and Health Sciences Admissions Test (or UMAT) is used to select students for medicine, dentistry and health sciences at 13 Australian universities. It assesses general attributes and abilities, including the acquisition of skills in critical thinking and problem solving, understanding people and abstract non-verbal reasoning. Participating universities take the results of this test into account alongside a student’s ATAR.

The Law Admissions Test (LAT) was recently introduced for law studies at the University of New South Wales, students’ LAT score is added to the ATAR as ‘additional points’ (UNSW Law, 2017). The LAT is designed to assess ‘aptitudes and skills that are critical to success in the law program, including critical thinking and analysis, and organising and expressing ideas in a clear and fluid way’.

Computer-based Assessment for Sampling Personal Characteristics (CASPer) was implemented for admission to initial teacher education courses in Victoria. The CASPer tests applicants’ personal and professional attributes, such as motivation to teach, resilience and organisation and planning skills.

Most universities offer Special Entry Access Schemes or Education Access Schemes which enable students experiencing disadvantage to add bonus points to their ATAR.

Some schemes enable school principals to make special recommendations for students they believe are capable of performing well at university despite underperforming in the ATAR, others offer direct entry to disadvantaged students before the main round of admissions and therefore bypass the use of ATAR.

Another growing pathway to admission is through shorter courses or qualifications designed to prepare students for bachelor level study. They aim to provide more supportive environments for school leavers, bridging the gap between school and more independent university study. These courses provide entry into the second year of a bachelor degree, or the results can be taken into account in a separate application process.

Selection methods such as interviews, portfolios, auditions and admission essays enable universities to get a more complete picture of student aptitudes not captured by a tertiary ranking, as well as gathering the more contextual factors necessary to determine how well a student is suited to a particular field of study.

Some universities use interviews for highly selective courses, while portfolios are more commonly used for studies in creative areas.

There are also equity considerations with these methods. While they provide a fuller picture of students who may have been disadvantaged by selection processes relying on school results, it is difficult to guarantee transparency.

While the authors aren’t advocating a scrapping of ATAR they feel some changes should be considered.

Any rethink of the system should include matching a student’s abilities, as well as his or her interests and aptitudes to a course of study or career pathway and ensuring students’ decisions are not unduly distorted by the perceived prestige of one institution over another. 

14 Nov 2018 | National
Nowhere to run for cheaters News Image

While it’s prevalent at universities, cheaters’ days might be numbered as markers have shown themselves to be adept at indentifying which assignments are not the work of the student and the ability improves with training. Read More

13 Nov 2018 | National
Catholic School Principals plan for future News Image

As the current crop of Catholic School Principals retires there’s concern that no one is stepping up to the plate, The Catholic Schools’ Middle Leadership Program addresses the development of new leaders. Read More

13 Nov 2018
Students asked which anti-smoking ads work best News Image

Quit Victoria’s annual Critics’ Choice initiative invites students to appraise anti-smoking ads and high school students are being called upon to get involved.
Read More

13 Nov 2018 | National
Program sees autistic toddlers thrive in mainstream kinder News Image

Toddlers with autism can thrive in normal kindergarten environments if provided with the correct scaffolding and La Trobe University’s Group-Early Start Denver Model (G-ESDM) looks to be one intervention that works well. Read More

12 Nov 2018 | Queensland
Students sing their Songs of Belonging with Opera Queensland’s help News Image

Yeronga State High School in inner-south Brisbane school has partnered with Opera Queensland to develop a stripped back opera to spotlight the stories and vocal abilities of its diverse student body. Read More