Education Today Logo


Education Today Cover Browse Issue

New evidence to suggest mindfulness can be harmful

Mindfulness is increasingly being used in classrooms to reduce stress and bring calm to the learning environment and to help students cope with their own stress and anxiety.

Dr Leigh Burrows, Senior Lecturer in Flinders University’s School of Education, says that teachers should be experienced mindfulness practitioners who know how to adapt activities for vulnerable students before they teach or offer mindfulness as some people find mindfulness meditation to be upsetting, triggering adverse reactions such as feelings of anxiety and “emotional flooding”.

“Mindfulness is a deep and powerful healing process that has clear and measurable benefits for a lot of people,” Burrows said. “Until recently the sole research focus has been on whether it works, but there is now evidence that it can have harmful effects on adults who have a history of post-traumatic stress, depression, abuse or other psychological conditions or disabilities.

“It is reasonable, then, to consider that some young people may also have negative experiences.

“In my research I asked a group of US community college students about their experiences during mindfulness and their answers show it isn’t always positive. Some students reported feelings of heightened anxiety, panic and freaking out.”

Burrows said teachers looking to use mindfulness in their classrooms should:

  • Have at least three years’ background in their own practice of mindfulness
  • Take student vulnerability into consideration when planning activities
  • Invite people to participate in an inclusive, “opt in” setting, rather than make participation compulsory
  • Recognise that mindfulness prompts unique responses in individuals
  • Seek feedback from students to guide any necessary adjustments and provide links to school and counselling where necessary

Dr Burrows suggested teachers should consider other effective, “emotionally neutral” activities including movement and the arts.

30 Apr 2017 | Australia
New Stephanie Alexander Kitchen Garden recipes and activities book News Image

The Stephanie Alexander Kitchen Garden Foundation (SAKGF) has launched its latest educational resource Step-by-Step Visual Cooking and Gardening: Accessible Recipes and Garden Activities. Read More

29 Apr 2017 | Australia
Schools not dressing girls for success News Image

School uniform codes that force female students to wear dresses and skirts are discriminatory and are affecting girls’ health and wellbeing according to Girls’ Uniform Agenda, an organisation launched in March. Read More

28 Apr 2017 | International
High test results in Asian schools, but at what cost News Image

The OECD recently published the findings of its first student well-being study. It shows that while East Asian countries are at the top of the league table of test scores they are at the bottom in student well-being. Read More

27 Apr 2017 | NSW
Applications for 2017 NSW Eco Schools Grants now open News Image

Educators and school communities in NSW are once again being encouraged to apply for an Eco Schools Grant to encourage their students to learn about the environment and develop an appreciation of it. Read More

27 Apr 2017 | Australia
Research: girls read while boys are encouraged in maths News Image

Girls from low and middle socio-economic backgrounds are better at reading than boys, while boys from high-socio-economic backgrounds are better at mathematics than girls, according to new research. Read More