Menu

Education Today Logo


newsletter

Education Today Cover Browse Issue

NAPLAN prep could be a distraction

News Image

Again some shade for NAPLAN, with the assessment due in May the focus on reparation may come at the expense of the rgular curriculum, says an education expert at the University of Technology Sydney (UTS).

Dr Don Carter is a senior lecturer in Teacher Education at UTS, with research interests in literacy development and curriculum design jointly conducted a study surveying 211 NSW English teachers, in which heavy criticism emerged of NAPLAN’s usefulness and of its relevance to students’ achievement, lives, or future prospects.

Carter and his fellow researchers, Assoc Prof Jacqueline Manuel (the University of Sydney) and Dr Janet Dutton (Macquarie University), asked teachers to rate their agreement or disagreement with statements about NAPLAN, and gave them a chance to write their own responses. Common themes emerged from the researchers’ analysis of these responses:

  • The NAPLAN tests added little to teachers’ understanding of students’ literacy levels
  • The assessment was a poor measure of student achievement
  • The tests had little relation to students’ lives, or to their future job prospects
  • Pressure to prepare students for NAPLAN detracted from other learning opportunities
  • Stress around the inflated importance of the test negatively impacted some students’ wellbeing; and
  • Pressure to 'teach to the test' frustrated many teachers, reducing their sense of professional autonomy.

The study recruited its participants through the NSW English Teachers’ Association social media platform. Carter cautions that the study should not be treated as a statistical analysis, but emphasises that it gives voice to professionals well-positioned to judge the test, bolstering existing evidence on both NAPLAN, and on standardised testing overseas.

Many of the teachers surveyed in the research disagreed with the statement that NAPLAN provided them with 'important information on the literacy skills' of their students. "I don’t need NAPLAN data to tell me which ones [students] can’t read or spell,” said one teacher.

Few teachers considered that the tests were 'an appropriate way to measure student achievement'. “The tests capture only a narrow aspect of a student’s capabilities,” said one participant.

Most teachers disagreed that NAPLAN tests 'are an important component in preparing students for future employment.' One teacher commented that the tests “couldn’t be less related to students’ lives if they tried”; another that the tests “have absolutely no relevance.”

Teachers were divided as to whether NAPLAN influenced their teaching practices, though many commented that they felt strong pressure to teach to the test. “I feel forced to teach to the test,” said one teacher. Another observed that “Every year we are told not to teach to the test, yet each year we are forced to do blatantly obvious teaching tasks that are ascribed to NAPLAN.”

According to  the research findings, “The external, institutional and other pressures on teachers to ‘teach to the test’ have an adverse impact on many teachers, serving to erode their professional agency and autonomy and engender frustration, anger and resentment. 

“They also consider that the validity of the NAPLAN tests and the credibility of the data on student performance is highly questionable. Further, despite the extensive government rhetoric surrounding the purpose of NAPLAN and the enormous financial resources directed to and derived from the tests, students’ achievement in literacy has not been lifted.”

The researchers suggest that it is not always clear to parents that the tests are not compulsory. “Information about how a parent can withdraw a child is buried on the ACARA website. Similarly, on the NESA website, it is not made clear to parents what the withdrawal arrangements are.”


19 Feb 2019 | India
Breakfast and lunch for better learning News Image

Breakfasts at school have had a great effect on learning outcomes and it looks like the same goes for lunch according to an investigation of 120 million Indian students. Read More

18 Feb 2019 | Melbourne
Ivanhoe university campus at Latrobe commences News Image

Ivanhoe Grammar School has opened its  University Campus for Year 9 at La Trobe University. It offers a year-long program designed to expose students to the self sufficiency of university life. Read More

18 Feb 2019 | National
Scrapping HECS debt for remote teachers welcomed News Image

Experts have endorsed the announcement that the government will cancel the uni debts of teachers who commit to working for four years in remote indigenous communities and say more must be done to attract locals to teaching. Read More

18 Feb 2019 | National
New $15k Reading Australia Fellowship for Teachers of English and Literacy open News Image

The Copyright Agency’s Cultural Fund has launched the new $15,000 Reading Australia Fellowship for Teachers of English and Literacy, part of almost $2m it awards every year. Read More

14 Feb 2019 | National
Yamaha’s 60K Great Start Grant – applications open News Image

Yamaha Music Australia’s Great Start Grant is a nationwide initiative with a very generous $60,000 worth of musical instruments given to the winning school and more. Read More