Out of all the information that is generated by NAPLAN one thing is becoming increasingly clear; results match socio-economic status.
New Macquarie University research finds a school’s location is becoming increasingly important for NAPLAN results. The study is the first localised spatial analysis of educational differences between schools across an entire country.
Educational differences have increased since the first NAPLAN – between schools in different areas, in cities, and between regional and metropolitan areas of Australia and results within cities have become more geographically polarised.
The researchers analysed every school’s Grade 5 NAPLAN results from 2008 to 2016, using mapping software. The team found that above average and below average school results are increasingly concentrated in different parts of every city (see diagram below). Further, non-government schools performed better than public schools in disadvantaged areas.
“The results reflect a widening spatial divide within Australia’s cities in terms of socioeconomic characteristics, such as parents’ education levels, incomes, and occupations,” said Prof Nick Parr from Macquarie University’s Department of Management, one of the study’s authors.
“Our findings show the area a school is based in has more bearing on NAPLAN results than whether the school is public or private,” said lead author Crichton Smith, a PhD candidate at Macquarie University’s Faculty of Business and Economics.
“The results are confronting. Virtually no schools in any city’s advantaged suburbs are below the national average, and almost no schools in disadvantaged areas are above average.
“Education quality should not be limited by a school’s location. Unfortunately the location-based divide has increased since NAPLAN began.
“With 10 years of NAPLAN results now available, it is difficult to see a policy solution to bridge a gap that is so wide, and growing. As it stands, those children whose families lack the means to live in, and more so for those living outside of the cities or send them to schools in advantaged areas; disadvantaged areas are increasingly missing out.”
The study is the world’s first school-level spatial analysis of educational differences across an entire country, and confirms a disadvantage across rural and regional Australia.
“We found significant differences between towns of different sizes. The proportion of both government and non-government schools with below average NAPLAN results increases as schools become more remote from major cities,” said Parr.
“Across remote Australia, just 20 schools had above average NAPLAN results, compared with over 200 schools below average.”
The findings provide evidence of Australia’s spatial educational inequality – and demonstrate that geographical information systems can be used to identify clustering patterns.
“We’ve shown NAPLAN can be used in a positive way by providing evidence of Australia’s increasingly observable spatial educational inequality,” added Smith.
“It doesn’t matter who owns the school, it’s where the school is located that matters”.
The Macquarie University research has been published in Geographical Research.
Year 12 is both a start and an ending and this period of change can be stressful. But there is help available if kids seem to be struggling with their mental health.
There are a few anxious school leavers right now, maybe they didn't get the ATAR they needed for the course they wanted or maybe they didn’t pass at all, but fear not there is more than one way to skin a cat. Read More
Located on the Victoria-New South Wales (NSW) border, Wodonga Middle Years College (WMYC) has leveraged technology so every student can access education from anywhere at any time. Read More
The 2018 national winners of the Young ICT Explorers competition have been announced with teams from Queensland and Australian Capital Territory taking home the top prizes. Read More